the first East Meets West Rally
Apostle Islands, Bayfield, Wisconsin * August 13-20, 2011
Report by Alan Asselstine
...

Apostle Islands Rally – August 13 – 20, 2011

Several years of discussions on an East meets West rally resulted in this first Apostle Islands rally. The location was the Apostle Islands National Shore on the south shore of Lake Superior, "Gitche Gumee", near Bayfield, Wisconsin. (A map of the park is available.) With 9 Wayfarers and 21 sailors we were a small but enthusiastic group. The participants were:

Boat

Number

Captain

Crew

Njord

W9657

Andrew Haill - Thunder Bay, ON

Lori Beehler - Thunder Bay, ON


W767

Chuck Jordan - Eau Claire, WI

Ginny Jordan - Eau Claire, WI

SHADES

W3854

Uncle Al - Oakville, ON

Richard Watterson - Hummelstown, PA

Bindlestiff

W7923

Ian Coxhead - Madison, WI

Robert Nelson

Orange Bottom*

W3445

Robert Mosher - Lansing, MI

John & Alex Kolstoe, then Andy Ivancic - Thunder Bay, ON

Orange Top*


Susannah Tellschow Wagner - Lansing, MI

Stephen Wagner - Lansing, MI

Jaa Rik

W907

Sean Ring - Cincinnati, OH

Quinn Ring - Cincinnati, OH

Port Tack too

W9913

Andy Douma - Ottawa, ON

Janet Foster - Ottawa, ON

Merriweather

W3101

Paul Ormseth - St Paul, MN

Alan & Mary Asselstine - Ottawa, ON

* These were the names given to these boats during the rally.


Most sailors camped at the Beaver Pond Campground beside the Casino in Red Cliff. The others had motel, condo or house accommodation in Bayfield, 3 miles south. The beach at Red Cliff was the boat mooring and launch point.


Saturday 13 August  – Arrival Day

Robert Mosher had arrived Friday. Early Saturday, John Kolstoe and son, Alex, arrived and joined Robert in sailing around Basswood Island and to Madeline Island’s west shore. They started with good wind that dropped off to none after rounding the south end of Basswood. By evening campfire time, all participants had arrived except Ian, who was not due until Sunday. Four boats were on the beach and four were ready to be launched in the morning.


Sunday 14 August – Hermit Island (no need to go to Maine)
The day was warm and sunny. However, with light winds and a short sailing day, as some boats still had to be launched, the planned sail was to go around Basswood Island and find a place to have lunch on the east side of Basswood. Eight Wayfarers set out – Merriweather, Jaa Rik, SHADES, Njord, Port Tack too, the Jordans, Orange Top and Orange Bottom. In light winds, the fleet made it to the north tip of Basswood where the Honeymoon Sea Stack sits. With SHADES taking the lead, the fleet sailed around Honeymoon Sea Stack.

No suitable landing spot was found on Basswood. So, with 5-8 knot north westerly winds, we set out for a beach on the south shore of Hermit Island. After a very pleasant sail, the fleet landed on the stony Hermit Island beach. The water was surprisingly warm, so many went for a swim. The beach was stony but Port Tack Too managed to get her centre board stuck with sand that had to be loosened before setting sail for home.This time the planned route was to sail east of Basswood and around its southern tip back to Red Cliff. The crew of SHADES decided it was getting late and went inside of Basswood. After a good start, the winds died at the south end of Basswood and out came the oars and paddles. No boat had a motor. As we worked toward Red Cliff, we saw SHADES and a second Wayfarer. SHADES was moving well under paddle. The second Wayfarer was Bindlestiff with Ian aboard, rowing.  Everyone had arrived.

As it was 7:00 PM when the boats were pulled out, the tailgate party was postponed until after dinner. The party became a campfire meet-and-greet session.  John & Alex then continued on their trip to see family in Minnesota.


Monday 15 August – La Pointe, Madeline Island
With 5 – 10 knot southerlies beating up to La Pointe in the morning and running home in the afternoon was the plan. Robert Nelson, a sailing instructor staying by himself at the campground, joined our group and crewed for Ian. And Andy Ivancic had arrived just in time to replace the departed Kolstoes on Robert Mosher's Orange Bottom. The crew of SHADES wanted to go to the Apostle Islands Marina in Bayfield to see Tom and Cyn Bloom aboard Savannah. Richard and Al had met the Blooms at the Rock Hall YC earlier in the summer. After a good start, the fleet was becalmed at the south end of Basswood. SHADES looked to be moving well along the shore near Bayfield. Had Uncle Al chosen the right route? SHADES disappeared into Bayfield. The Blooms were not home but Richard and Al did buy a Leatherman at Ace Hardware.

The southerlies finally picked up again and the fleet arrived at La Pointe by 2:00 for lunch, ice cream and a walk past the busy Burnt Down Café. Chuck had arranged for us to pull out on a private beach near the ferry dock. Just before 3:00 SHADES arrived from Bayfield and joined the fleet for the run back to Red Cliff. For the first time ever, Andy Douma flew the Port Tack too spinnaker. It was another campfire night of visiting.


Tuesday 16 August – Oak Island
With a 5 to 10-knot south wind, it was going to be a run to the pier on the south shore of Oak Island. A fleet of seven boats set sail at a little after 11:00. We set up a rendez-vous off Red Cliff Point and changed our destination to the sand spit on the south shore of Oak Island. At the Point, the crew of SHADES advised that they were turning back to try to visit Long Island. Well, after a spirited beat, Uncle Al and Richard met Chuck who was taking his two sets of guests, from Oklahoma and from Traverse Bay,.out sailing in W767 This was the last Apostles sailing day for Richard and Al since Al was loath to miss any of the Hermit Island Rally in Maine and had leave Wednesday so that he could pick up Julia in Oakville on the Friday and continue on to Maine. An offer to join Chuck and Bill Smethells (the Traverse friend who had bought Chuck's first W) on a run over to Tom's Burned Down Café  was too good to pass up. So they decided to take SHADES out early and and then took the Madeline Island ferry to the Café.

The rest of the fleet continued north to the sand spit on Oak Island. It was a good landing place with a soft beach and a picnic area. Unfortunately, it was exposed to the south wind which built to 12 knots. Sails were reefed and JR and Port Tack Too set sail. Unfortunately, Bindlestiff's centreboard got sand into its centreboard box and was stuck. After 20 minutes, the board was freed and the rest of the fleet also set sail for Red Cliff. With the 12-knot winds gusting to 15, it was an enjoyable sail.

This evening, all were invited to Chuck and Ginny Jordan’s place for a Wisconsin-style BBQ of Brats and burgers. It was the big social event of the rally. A nice chance to say good-bye to Uncle Al, Richard and Ian who were leaving in the morning. The food was great and the conversation stimulating. It was a chance to meet Chuck and Ginny's family and friends. Many of us discovered New Glarus and Leinenkugel beer and so found that Wisconsin can produce “real” beer not the more commercial stuff available outside the state.

There was a pregnant pause in mid-evening as host Chuck called us all out onto the deck where the downpour had lessened. In a surprise ceremony, Alan Asselstine and Uncle Al were made honorary cheeseheads and fans of Wisconsin's world-famous Green Bay Packers football team.


August 17 and 18 – Mini or Overnight Cruise to Stockton Island
Andrew suggested an overnight cruise to Stockton Island and eight others agreed to come along in a total of four boats. In addition, Jaa Rik with Sean and Quinn sailed out with the fleet to see us off but then went back as they were heading south on the 18th. The forecast winds were 15 to 20 knots from the west, so it would be a fast run to Stockton Island. While we were in the lee of the Bayfield peninsula, our winds were in the 12 to 15 knot range. But by the time we reached the north tip of Basswood, the winds had reached 20 knots. Merriweather and Njord hove to in the lee of Basswood and again in the lee of Hermit Island to let the fleet re-group. The recently purchased Orange Top lacked some equipment for sailing in these conditions, and was being sailed downwind in an admirably cautious manner. Orange Bottom used this opportunity to go downwind, upwind, and on reaches to improve their heavy-wind sailing skills, while always sticking close to Orange Top for safety.

From Hermit Island, the fleet set off on the longest run to Presque Isle Point on Stockton Island. The wind continued to build and according to the park ranger, some gusts hit 25 knots as waves reached four feet. According to our GPS's, Orange Bottom reached a speed of 9.4 knots and Merriweather hit 9.6 knots as they planed down the waves. All four boats soon reached our destination of Presque Isle Point on Stockton Island. Orange Top and Njord landed on the windward (west) side of the point in Presque Isle Bay, while Merriweather and Orange Top rounded the point to land on the leeward side of the point in Julian Bay.

Both sides offered beaches on which to land our boats though the boats on the west side had to be pulled well up to avoid the waves. The camp sites were on the west side and so two nice sites with bear boxes were staked out. The east shore offered a large quiet beach off which several yachts were anchored for the night. We decided to have supper on this lee side beach so the crews of the windward side boats made the half-mile trek across the point since that side was much more comfortable. It was a great place to swim, relax and eat after the invigorating sail. There was time for exploratory walks around the end of the point or along the beach. Camping was prohibited on this east beach, so the crews of Merriweather and Orange Bottom decided to join the yachts and sleep under boom tents aboard their boats which they anchored. Sleeping aboard is an experience all Wayfarers should enjoy, especially with a moon- and starlit night and no mosquitoes or bears.

In the morning, those who needed to, walked back to the west shore for breakfast, to check the winds and to launch Orange Top and Njord. On the path was fresh bear scat, to remind us whose home this really was. Today's plan was to sail straight back to Red Cliff. Orange Top and Njord would do some exploring along the shore, while the other boats set sail and came around the point in the now pleasant winds of about 5 knots from the south. All was going well as we made 3 to 4 knots with the southerlies.

Then over the radio from Orange Bottom came the word “Do not come here; it has turned to glass.” Soon no boat was going anywhere as the lake was like glass all around us. A couple of hours of changeable to no winds followed. One shift gave us thirty minutes of about 4 knot winds from the north. With paddles and catching any wind available, we closed in on the north tip of Basswood Island. At last we saw a wind coming from the south and suddenly we were sailing in 12 knots. The result was a good sail back to Red Cliff. The mini- or one-day cruise had been a success for the participants.

Thursday evening was the black-tie night. We got dressed up and gathered at the camp ground for the Wayfarer equivalent of a yacht club social night. The pictures best describe the good natured and enjoyable social evening led by Lori and Andrew.


August 19 – Last Sailing day and a quick sail to Bayfield
Two boats, Port tack too and Njord, each with a crew of three, set out in variable southerlies for the three-mile sail to Bayfield. Others drove to town. The destination was the Sailing Club beach near Mary and Alan's condo. After a short walk around town, all gathered for BBQed fresh white fish by the water at the condo. Even Robert, who is not a fish eater had seconds. Then it was a quick sail back to Red Cliff and the job of taking the boats out. Paul and Andy I., with shorter drives to Thunder Bay, headed home. Those remaining marked the end of the rally with a meal made by emptying their coolers.


August 20 to 27 - Robert Mosher’s post-rally cruise
I left on Saturday and sailed up behind Long Island (that sand spit Al and Richard wanted to see earlier in the week) but contrary to weather predictions, it was a lee shore so I ran for Madeline Island's Big Bay. Next day I stopped at Michigan Island and climbed the Light House, then stayed at Stockton Island.  Next day it was on to Outer Island's north shore which is barely safe and only with a south wind. Luck was with me and the wind stayed to the South. I met Craig Blacklock (Mr. Lake Superior) nature photographer who had kayaked out, and two girls who were just coming back from 7 days in the woods counting plants. 

The next day I wanted to beat the bad weather but did not, so settled for Cat Island. On the way to Cat, I was counting seconds from the lighting strikes, and waited for the wind to hit hard. Spent the next day on Cat Island Beach with the sun shining, 20 plus mph wind, gusting to 34, with sudden gusts. Picked up some trash and killed sand flies. On Thursday it was on to Rocky, followed by Devils Island. Friday in rip-roaring winds and waves. After turning back from the North end route which was too wild, I finally got my groove on and was hiking out and sailing hard. I swear the waves would explode half-way up to the spreaders when I hit them just right. Good thing I had my dry top on. Sailed into Devils Island Harbor which impressed all the local sailors who always motor in. Next morning was my birthday. Got up early, walked the Island and climbed the lighthouse. I then rowed from the South end to the North (1.5mi) looking at sea caves and rocks. Around 3:00 PM, I started back to Red Cliff. I could have stayed at Raspberry or Oak Island but wanted to sail all the way back in one go. The winds were light and frustrating. I pulled up on shore in the Harbor at 1:55 AM. Pulled out the sleeping pads and bag, then pulled the sail over me and went to sleep.  It had been a great day.



Post-Script
With 9 boats and 21 sailors and great weather the rally was a success. Most of those participating plan to return to the Apostle Islands. New friendships were forged and preliminary discussions were made on the subject of a Lake of the Woods cruise or rally.  Others expressed an interest in a Michigan rally.